Stinger GT vs Audi S5 - and the winner is ................

westcoastGT

5000 Posts Club!
Joined
Sep 29, 2017
Messages
7,224
Reaction score
3,157
Points
118
Location
Vancouver , Canada
Two style-focused V6 four-doors do battle, as the new Kia Stinger takes on the premium Audi S5

Ten years ago few people would have guessed that Kia, the South Korean manufacturer best known for its reasonably priced hatchbacks, SUVs and superminis, would bring out a car that directly rivals one of Audi’s most accomplished fast family models. Yet that is exactly what has happened with this, the Kia Stinger GT S, which has set its sights firmly on the Audi S5 Sportback.

It’s a big leap for a company such as Kia to take on a brand like Audi – but the Stinger’s 3.3-litre twin-turbo V6 ensures it has the performance to rival the S5, even if the £40,495 price means it’ll have to impress buyers used to premium models.

The Kia does undercut the Audi on price, but can it really manage a win over the establishment?

For: Surprisingly fun to drive, lots of equipment, comfortable ride.
Against: Engine could be more exciting, finish lacking in some areas, pricier on finance.

A high-end sports saloon with 365bhp from Kia will be a surprise to many, but it’s time to get used to the idea because the car is here, and it’s well worth a look. The eye-catching design means the new Stinger looks the part. However, what’s really impressive about the brand’s first attempt at a sports saloon for the European market is that it delivers competitive performance and a genuinely enjoyable drive.

While the Stinger was slightly slower than the Audi from 0-60mph in our tests, taking 4.9 seconds to the S5’s 4.7 seconds, the Kia was actually faster once it was rolling. The Audi’s four-wheel-drive system means it launches ferociously, but the Kia was a tenth quicker from 30-70mph through the gears, posting a time of 3.9 seconds. Read more: Kia Stinger vs Audi S5
 
Both are wonderful cars and I cross shopped them both. The tech is way better in the Audi and will be for years to come IMO. But I agree the Stinger is a more comfortable ride than the S5.
 
Both are wonderful cars and I cross shopped them both. The tech is way better in the Audi and will be for years to come IMO. But I agree the Stinger is a more comfortable ride than the S5.
What tech in the Audi are you referring too ??
 
______________________________
The virtual cockpit
 
The virtual cockpit
Not sure I understand what youre saying ?? functionality , look , tactile issues ?? I've never been in the Audi
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
This video will give you an idea. Some people like the analog tach and speedo but I'm a geek and tech lover and enjoy the virtual cockpit and it's customizable interface.

 
This video will give you an idea. Some people like the analog tach and speedo but I'm a geek and tech lover and enjoy the virtual cockpit and it's customizable interface.

OK , got it ! Thanks :thumbup:
 
As more reviews come out, I think we will see the Stinger beat a lot of its competitors or match them on performance. Its level of material is not at their level but overall for what it is as a package, it is a hard car to beat.
 
As more reviews come out, I think we will see the Stinger beat a lot of its competitors or match them on performance. Its level of material is not at their level but overall for what it is as a package, it is a hard car to beat.
Have you seen the News and Media section here , check out the vid I posted Stinger vs Panamera vs BMW 640 , lots of other great reviews and vids in there too .:thumbup::thumbup:
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I've seen a bunch of them. This car is making waves in the industry.
 
______________________________
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Nice find! I bet the GT AWD would match or beat the S5 0-60 since Alex on Autos got 4.6s.

As a prior '17 A4 owner (A5 same interior), I don't agree the interior is that much better. The Stinger only falls short in the cheap steering wheel cover and rear vents/console plastic.
 
Last edited:
This video will give you an idea. Some people like the analog tach and speedo but I'm a geek and tech lover and enjoy the virtual cockpit and it's customizable interface.


That display is impressive! The Audi also has a better AWD system as it can not only distribute power front to rear but also side to side by using limited slip differentials. So if you lose traction at one of the rear wheels, the system ADD's power to the other rear wheel. The Stinger's set up also does this BUT because it has open differentials at the front and rear, if a rear wheel starts to slip, the brake is applied at that wheel forcing the open diff to put power to the wheel with traction. If the system is engaged a lot it could result in excessive brake wear but the open diff set up is more durable (except for the brakes) because of the simpler set up. The Audi's system is more complicated, however it is a proven system.
 
I find it funny, that some review quote some "for 8k more you get that Audi, is it worth that?". I dunno, but if I configure an Audi with the same options I get in the Kia, I'm way, way, WAY further ahead than 8k .. but I'd have to check again, maybe somethign changed.

As for "Sportscar", I'm not interested much in that in the Stinger. The Stinger is not a Sportscar. At 1900 KG weight and close to 5m in lenght, you're not a Lotus Elise. It's a speedy, comfy GT, and that's what I want it to me. Competing with an M3 CSL is nonsense, not the same class of car.
 
Last edited:
Quickly checked this in Switzerlands Audi Konfigurator:

Here, I can only order one Stinger ... in Switzerland we get a fully loaded one with every option possible in. KIA asks around 58500 CHF for this (roughly the same in USD as the currencies atm are very close).

At Audi, I picked the S5 and loaded it with only the extras the Stinger has and deliberatly avoided any special leather extras or whatever virtual cockpit etc. Endprice is 95'000.

That's more than 35'000 USD more. So no, at least to me here in Switzerland, the distance is enormous an nowhere near a "little" 8k.
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
In the UK, an S5 is £48, hence where people are getting the £8k.

However you are right, just adding the extra's you'll easily add £12k to it to spec it the same. I also spec'ed a BMW Grand Coupe M Sport 435i, and that was very much the same cost. A Merc CLA starts at £45k ... but still ends at around the £58-59k ... plus I couldn't fit in the back of a CLA, compared to the Stinger where I can sit up straight in back.

There are not that many cars that are the same style and performance in the UK ... lack of american muscle cars.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top