Bad Nightmare at JT’s Kia of Rock Hill, SC

KyleSC

Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2019
Messages
54
Reaction score
45
Points
18
My Kia Nightmare

I’ve read a lot of dealer praise and dealer problems on this forum, but what happened here goes beyond the word nightmare. Had my Stinger GT2 brought in on a flatbed after the driver turbo blew a seal and emptied the oil through the exhaust. Towed to my house as it was close by and looked at the compressor fan. The edges were damaged and it broke the seal. I took out an air box, 2 pieces of tubing, and the driver side recirculation valve. I made an appointment and had the flat bed transport it there. Told the writer up front that I took the mentioned parts off to take a look, and couldn’t find the recirculation valve and the 2 pieces of tubing. Told him..my fault on those, I’ll pay to replace them. Next morning he called abruptly stated they are denying warranty claim for all of. I asked for manager who recommended calling Kia customer service and they would likely approve it and they did. Kia said they received the report, when I talked to the Service Manager 2 days later he stated he has to submit a report (which Kia said they have) for official approval (which Kia gave me 2 days earlier). I said “Rick would you mind CC the report to me?” He said he would. Guess what. No report sent to me. I follow up and more and more BS about the approval. Call Kia and they said we did approve it. I’m already documenting everything at this point and verifying anything they say. Back to dealership...I talked to Kia they authorized 7 days ago. Please check your system while we are on the phone and let’s get this turbo ordered. Oh..oh..ok we’ll get that ordered. Yes, it gets a lot worse....follow up call days later...”I ordered it beau, but no telling when it’ll get here. Hell it may not have been built yet” -where’s it coming from? “South Korea” -it’s a Garrett, believe they’re made in the US. Why would they build it here only to ship it to Korea, to then ship it back. Don’t you have part distribution centers? “Yea, but this is on Backorder“...2 weeks later. “Still on backorder” ...makes no sense to me either. I hit the internet and contact OEM Kia parts sites and discover it’s not on backorder and can ship in 2-3 days. Back to Kia customer service I advise now I’m recording all communications upfront. Told her what I found out, she read the notes, then took notes and stated my case manager will call back today.....crickets. I call again a day later and get a nice rep same story with me case mgr. I asked her to see if the dealer ordered the part and gave the part#. They did, days after what they told me and received it 12 days ago...I have that call recorded. I hang up and call the service rep “DJ” I stated upfront “our communications are now being recorded“ what’s the status on the turbo, DJ? Still on backorder....I just talked to Kia and they said that’s not true. In fact...it wasn’t on backorder. You ordered it several days after the date you told me, and it’s at the dealership. Oh..oh..oh...oh let me put you on hold and check the parts department. He comes back...”it’s here, just hasn’t been checked in yet” wow!!! It’s been there 12 days and hasn’t been checked in??? “Well sometimes it takes a while” —-that’s nutty. Let me speak to the GM. “Not available” have him call me....crickets..I call Kia to update them, and they ask if I’ve been told what I will owe for the 2 pieces of tubing and recirculation valve. I told her I looked the parts up and couldn’t believe they were $200, but I lost them so I will pay. She said the dealer said $800. I told her I will not pay that and asked why it was so high. The dealer stated that it comes as an assembly and that is the only way to order it. I told her they either don’t know how to look up parts or they’re trying to pull a fast one. Advised I’ll send proof tonight....sent 5 screenshots of shopping carts with parts listed individually. No call back. Check dealer, car will be ready next week. Pick up car...looks like shit. Starts smoking on the way home. No coolant and coolant hoses weren’t secured. I clamped them. Data logged from my phone and under load timing was 7 degrees and AFR was rich....10:1. Called service manager and said I’m not dealing with DJ. Asked him about the $800 bill and said will have to check with regional parts manager. Next day...he said no go. I said I’ll pay for the parts, but not your mistake. Offered to meet me half way $400. I asked why he would need to get approval to cover their mistake. Told him I want someone who isn’t thinking in terms of how cheap they deal with this to think about all the headache, lies, and BS and imagine it was them it happened to and get back to me. Crickets,,,I call Kia cares update them again....go through the whole ordeal.....oh, also when I looked the engine over there were over a dozen missing bolts....important bolts, not bullshit bolts. I sent 20 photos to service managers...crickets, then called Kia. Gave account to one rep who stated this is serious misconduct and then another rep called me and I went through it line by line. She agreed with my account, I offered recordings, take a video of the shit job they did, even put a snazzy report together with Adobe Illustrator. She said she’s taking care of that and it’s going to Kia regional VP or something, and the dealership’s owner. How will Kia be successful if their dealers treat their products, and more importantly their own customers like shit...think twice before driving into that parking lot.
 
I tried counting the missing bolts, but there were so many that I kept losing count. Thank God for colored stickers.......I’m going to provide some context......What should Kia do, what do y’all think is fair? The lying, trying to gouge me, and shit work quality
 

Attachments

  • 91FEABE5-7CCB-4FDB-8956-E71FB594F376.webp
    91FEABE5-7CCB-4FDB-8956-E71FB594F376.webp
    207.1 KB · Views: 49
  • AC7683B2-861E-454D-934D-C02A3E6E5EAC.webp
    AC7683B2-861E-454D-934D-C02A3E6E5EAC.webp
    238.3 KB · Views: 49
  • C7C1BB5A-0C9B-440B-85BF-F5FA2B86B84D.webp
    C7C1BB5A-0C9B-440B-85BF-F5FA2B86B84D.webp
    187.6 KB · Views: 47
  • DBEE9196-E452-44C1-8C36-E87224D3C2BD.webp
    DBEE9196-E452-44C1-8C36-E87224D3C2BD.webp
    198.9 KB · Views: 45
  • AFD06514-8759-43FB-9EEB-BEDD7B33454A.webp
    AFD06514-8759-43FB-9EEB-BEDD7B33454A.webp
    287.7 KB · Views: 43
  • 153C816A-822E-458E-A0B2-CCC42AB8DD20.webp
    153C816A-822E-458E-A0B2-CCC42AB8DD20.webp
    272.6 KB · Views: 42
  • 54DFA3BA-559C-4B04-BB7B-1C1DB7595884.webp
    54DFA3BA-559C-4B04-BB7B-1C1DB7595884.webp
    297.4 KB · Views: 37
  • 3D1EE209-5874-4AED-9107-4E7BA97E4180.webp
    3D1EE209-5874-4AED-9107-4E7BA97E4180.webp
    150 KB · Views: 35
  • C194ED47-9024-4EE9-8673-1BB0C2F385CF.webp
    C194ED47-9024-4EE9-8673-1BB0C2F385CF.webp
    314.1 KB · Views: 36
  • 2016A01E-AEA6-42DA-9E50-8D86093B8E25.webp
    2016A01E-AEA6-42DA-9E50-8D86093B8E25.webp
    267.7 KB · Views: 50
______________________________
Dude what a nightmare!
 
Wow so sorry for you!
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Wall, of, text! *sigh*!

But it's so gripping that I had no difficulty reading the whole thing.

What's justice here is someone further up in Kia Corp. taking your side entirely, which would result in paying to get your car entirely sorted out in an expeditious manner; and then eat your monthly payments that your car was out of commission. (what Kia Corp. does with ratted out, ratty "service" centers, is up to Kia; but if they want to improve their customer satisfaction rating they have to weed out the ratty dealerships)
 
Wow so sorry for you!
Thanks guys. Last Kia cares rep said a regional manager would contact me this week. Thus far, Kia cares has taken notes for my case manager who doesn’t call back. Next step in my state is Arbitration, which I will do if not resolved this week. It’s a process, and it pays to have documentation, phone call recordings (with advised) consent, and emails specifically expressing your concerns. I’ll see this all the way through and give updates and details on the process. Don’t want any of you guys to have to deal with something like this and, if patient, I’m confident it will be handled.
 
This is a nightmare but one thing I'll mention is that a lot of the spots you marked as having missing bolts arent supposed to have bolts in them. They are threaded like a bolt is supposed to be in them but its normal that they dont have anything in them as they were just needed for assembly reasons or something at the factory. Some locations are missing foam pieces that they probably either broke or were too lazy to put back on so yes it is missing some bolts and pieces for sure. Goodluck!
 
This is automotive insanity.
 
Kia cares will tell the victim, sorry, "customer" what they should be told. Now, there is little chance of anything happening, outside of you just telling your story to Kia. What does corporate usually tell customers that have complaints? "Sorry. There is nothing we can do. Each dealer is independent".

On a side note, that dealer really sucks, but it seems you have a handle on it, and I really hope you win in arbitration and/or court.
 
______________________________
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
Kia cares will tell the victim, sorry, "customer" what they should be told. Now, there is little chance of anything happening, outside of you just telling your story to Kia. What does corporate usually tell customers that have complaints? "Sorry. There is nothing we can do. Each dealer is independent".

On a side note, that dealer really sucks, but it seems you have a handle on it, and I really hope you win in arbitration and/or court.
Exactly;
""Kia cares will tell the victim, sorry, "customer" what they should be told. Now, there is little chance of anything happening, outside of you just telling your story to Kia. What does corporate usually tell customers that have complaints?""

And espicially?

""Sorry. There is nothing we can do. Each dealer is independent".""

You get assigned a case manager. Then you call, case manager is never available, they take notes (seem to) and tell you they agree with you blah..blah, assure you they'll call you as soon as they finish their call, and nothing happens. It's a system. Be empathetic, assure the poor bastard they take it serious, and act more like therapists, but ultimately doing nothing. It's a strategy. Most people give up. They won't actually do anything until they know your not going away and they won't do anything until until they realize cost/aggravation outweighs their exposure.
 
""Sorry. There is nothing we can do. Each dealer is independent".""
That is what I got when I filed a detailed complaint about the dealer we bought the stinger from. They are 15 minutes from our house, no way will they ever get my car for service. We will drive 45 minutes to either of two other dealers in a different city. And only go there if we need warranty service.
 
This is terrible. Really sorry to hear this.

I can't help but contrast this story to my experience at my local Audi dealership. Completely opposite experience. My A4 Avant was out of warranty but because of the extensive documentation I had as well as my loyalty to the dealership, they agreed to fix its common oil consumption issue under warranty. Nearly a $10,000 claim as they pull the engine. It was finished and I had the car back in 2 days. It was detailed inside and out and hasn't used a drop of oil since. 80,000 km's and counting.

Kia corporate needs to step in and do something with their dealerships because stories like this crush consumer confidence. They could have a 30 year warranty but if they have "independent dealers" who deny, doddle and do shoddy work then what good is it?
 
This is terrible. Really sorry to hear this.

I can't help but contrast this story to my experience at my local Audi dealership. Completely opposite experience. My A4 Avant was out of warranty but because of the extensive documentation I had as well as my loyalty to the dealership, they agreed to fix its common oil consumption issue under warranty. Nearly a $10,000 claim as they pull the engine. It was finished and I had the car back in 2 days. It was detailed inside and out and hasn't used a drop of oil since. 80,000 km's and counting.

Kia corporate needs to step in and do something with their dealerships because stories like this crush consumer confidence. They could have a 30 year warranty but if they have "independent dealers" who deny, doddle and do shoddy work then what good is it?

It's crazy that you mentioned Audi because I'm currently battling with them about a titling issue. I bought a car from a Kansas Audi dealership in early September. They sent the title to my local DMV about a week later. Someone had scratched through a couple of the lines on the title, making it invalid. The DMV contacted Audi in mid-September and I've been waiting on a new title ever since. In 3 days my temporary registration expires and I won't be able to drive the car anymore until they pull their heads out of their asses.

More of a clerical issue than warranty issue but I think it highlights the fact that bad/stupid things can and will happen no matter the brand of car. Kia dealerships do have a lot of issues they need to work on but no car brand delivers perfect consumer satisfaction.
 
It's crazy that you mentioned Audi because I'm currently battling with them about a titling issue. I bought a car from a Kansas Audi dealership in early September. They sent the title to my local DMV about a week later. Someone had scratched through a couple of the lines on the title, making it invalid. The DMV contacted Audi in mid-September and I've been waiting on a new title ever since. In 3 days my temporary registration expires and I won't be able to drive the car anymore until they pull their heads out of their asses.

More of a clerical issue than warranty issue but I think it highlights the fact that bad/stupid things can and will happen no matter the brand of car. Kia dealerships do have a lot of issues they need to work on but no car brand delivers perfect consumer satisfaction.
That sucks. Is it the Dealer that sends the title or Audi USA?
 
From interior to exterior to high performance - everything you need for your Stinger awaits you...
That sucks. Is it the Dealer that sends the title or Audi USA?
The individual dealerships handle it. In my case the Kansas dealership bought the car from a Texas dealership and they BOTH messed up parts of the title. So I'm 0 for 2 with Audi dealership satisfaction, so far. Hopefully my local dealerships make up for it as the years go on.
 
______________________________
The individual dealerships handle it. In my case the Kansas dealership bought the car from a Texas dealership and they BOTH messed up parts of the title. So I'm 0 for 2 with Audi dealership satisfaction, so far. Hopefully my local dealerships make up for it as the years go on.
Ugh. Hopefully it's as you said and your local dealership experience is better.

Still, nothing as crazy as what the OP has gone through. Paperwork is one thing but mechanical/warranty issues are another altogether. I cringe at the thought of a Dealer like that touching my car.
 
30 mins on phone with rep today. Advised I was recording call. He vehemently expressed does not consent. Case manager unavailable (always). I calmly and rationally expressed my concern that this seems to be a lengthy therapy process (after multiple, "that's terrible", "so sorry your going through that". I changed to more detailed questions like, Kia's role, recourse, moral turpitude in franchise agreements, and still received the exact same response: "I will notify your case manager and she will be in touch". He stated again that dealerships are independent, then I asked if they are allowed to act with impunity? His answer was so scripted it easy to tell he was reading it. You have to go to arbitration. I did upload a 6 minute video yesterday and he confirmed receipt, but all in all, that department is a required waste of time when seeking results.
 
You should have gotten a lawyer the very second that they denied the warranty claim. I've had my own experiences with denied warranty work by Kia. They simply refused to fix the car over faulty brakes and the LSD. I called the lawyer as quickly as I could find a successful one. Kia got their car back, I got my money back. Sorry this has happened to you too.
 
Back
Top